Hi, I have tried both products. I like and use Hyper Dressing on a regular basis, but not so much for tires after trying the Tuff Shine. I applied Tuff Shine on my Girlfriends car about a month and a half ago and the tires still look pretty good, a nice low gloss satin black. I have only washed with ONR
since applying and have been through about three or four days of rain in that time. I found the key to getting this to work well is to have absolutely clean tires to start with. I scrubbed the tires once with 3M's All Purpose Cleaner and Degreaser, then twice with Tuff Shine's tire cleaner and finally P21S
TAW and a steamer. I applied 3 light coats with about 5 minutes between coats. The finish is dry to the touch with no greasy or oily film. I have seen other reviews of this product that say it is too glossy, maybe they are applying it very heavy or maybe they didn't rub it in as I did? I have only tried it on this one car but so far am very impressed, the fact that they are dry to the touch and low gloss is a plus for me. I'll be trying this on a few cars (along with my own) soon an will try get some pictures posted of how this looks.
Hope this helps, Dan.